How to Carry Extra Luggage on Your Car: 6 Options Compared
In this guide
Quick answer
For most cars and SUVs, the easiest way to add real luggage space is a set of crossbars plus a roof basket, cargo bag or roof box. If you have a 2-inch trailer hitch, a hitch cargo carrier carries more weight, is easier to load and costs far less fuel. No roof rails? You still have options: bare-roof crossbars clamp to the door frames. The table below compares all six ways, and what each one needs.
Holiday road trip, five people, one SUV, and the cargo area is full before the cooler goes in. Sound familiar? You don't need a bigger car. You need the right carrier for the car you already have.
This guide covers every practical way to carry extra luggage on a car: on the roof, on the hitch, and inside. For each one we explain what it needs, what it costs, and the mistakes that send people back to the store.
Find crossbars for my car → Compare all 6 options
First, answer 3 questions
Your answers decide which option fits your car and your trip.
- What's on your roof? Raised rails, flush rails, hidden fixed points, or nothing at all. Every roof can carry a rack, but each roof type takes a different crossbar. Not sure? Our 30-second roof-type check shows you how to tell.
- Do you have a 2-inch hitch receiver? If yes, a hitch cargo carrier is on the table, and it's often the best choice for heavy gear.
- What are you carrying? Soft duffels and sleeping bags suit a bag or basket. Suitcases you want dry and locked suit a hard box. Coolers, firewood and muddy gear belong on a hitch carrier.
The 6 ways to carry extra luggage, compared
| Option | What it needs | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Roof cargo basket | Crossbars | Bulky, odd-shaped gear; pairs with a bag or net | Cargo is open to rain unless covered |
| 2. Rooftop cargo bag | Crossbars (some bags strap through the doors) | Soft luggage, occasional trips, small storage space at home | Straps loosen; flaps in crosswinds |
| 3. Hard-shell roof box | Crossbars | Suitcases you want dry and locked, ski trips | Rear-hatch clearance; garage height; storage at home |
| 4. Hitch cargo carrier | 2-inch hitch receiver | Heavy, dirty or bulky gear; easy waist-height loading | Hitch tongue-weight limit; don't block lights or plate |
| 5. Soft roof pads | Nothing (straps run through the car) | A one-off light load on a car with no rails | Low weight limits; not for every roof or door |
| 6. Pack smarter inside | Nothing | Small overflow, short trips | Blocked rear view; loose items in a hard stop |
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.
Options 1 to 3 all sit on crossbars, the two bars that run side to side across your roof. If your car only has rails running front to back, you still need crossbars before any roof carrier will mount. We explain why in do I need crossbars if my car has roof rails?
1. Roof cargo basket: the all-rounder
A basket is an open steel tray that bolts to your crossbars. It takes almost anything: duffels, a cooler, camping chairs, a spare tire. You secure the load with straps or a cargo net, or strap a weather-resistant cargo bag inside it for rain.
- Pros: carries bulky or oddly shaped gear a box can't, quick to load, looks right on an SUV.
- Cons: cargo is exposed unless you cover it; adds wind noise and drag.
ERKUL AeroGlide Roof Cargo Basket
51" x 36" powder-coated steel · rated 175 lb · wind fairing · U-bolt mount fits most crossbars
$179.99
Shop the basketBasket tips: center the heaviest items between the crossbars, strap everything, and take the basket off before an automatic car wash. Remember the 175 lb rating covers the cargo, and the basket and bars count toward your car's roof limit too (more on that below).
2. Rooftop cargo bag: soft, cheap, folds away
A rooftop bag is a heavy-fabric bag that straps to crossbars or, on some designs, through the door openings. When the trip's over, it folds into a closet.
- Pros: low cost, light, easy to store, no tools.
- Cons: most are water-resistant rather than fully waterproof, straps loosen as the load settles, and a half-full bag flaps at speed. Keep electronics inside the car.
If you'll use a bag more than once or twice a year, mount it on crossbars. The load sits flatter, the straps have a solid anchor, and the bag can't shift on the roof paint.
3. Hard-shell roof box: dry and locked
A roof box is the classic ski-trip answer: a lockable shell that keeps suitcases dry. Every roof box mounts on crossbars, so the bars are the part to get right first.
- Pros: keeps rain off, locks, keeps luggage out of sight.
- Cons: expensive, bulky to store at home, and a large box can noticeably cut your highway mileage (see the numbers below).
Box tip: before you buy a box, open your rear hatch fully and check where it swings. Position the box far enough forward that the hatch clears it. For wide boxes, our Wizard crossbars have extended bar tips that give roof boxes and other wide loads extra room.
4. Hitch cargo carrier: the most capacity for the least effort
If your car has a 2-inch hitch receiver, a hitch carrier is often the smartest buy. You load it at waist height instead of over your head. It carries heavy, wet or dirty gear the roof shouldn't. And it rides behind the car, where it adds far less drag.
The U.S. Department of Energy measured the difference. On fueleconomy.gov, a large, blunt rooftop cargo box can cut fuel economy by about 6% to 17% on the highway and 10% to 25% at 65 to 75 mph. A rear-mount cargo box or tray costs only 1% to 5% on the highway.
ERKUL TrekHaul Hitch Cargo Carrier
58" x 20" powder-coated steel · rated 300 lb · fits 2" receivers (Class III or higher) · hitch pin and clip included
$199.99
Shop the carrier
ERKUL TrekHaul Hitch Cargo Bag
15 cu ft · heavy 525gsm PVC · water-resistant once zipped · turns an open hitch basket into a closed trunk
$60.99
Shop the bagHitch tips: your hitch has its own tongue-weight rating, and the lower of the hitch rating and the carrier's 300 lb wins. Strap or net everything down, and make sure nothing blocks your taillights or license plate. Still deciding between the two? See hitch cargo carrier vs roof basket.
5. Soft roof pads: a stopgap for cars with no rails
Foam pads strap to a bare roof, with the straps running through the car's door openings. They work for a one-off light load, like a mattress from the store or a single board. They are not a long-term luggage solution: weight limits are low, and they don't suit every car. Skip them on convertibles, on panoramic roofs that open fully, and on frameless doors.
If your roof is bare and you'll carry luggage more than once, real bare-roof crossbars are the better answer. They clamp to the door frames and take baskets, bags and boxes. See roof racks for cars without rails.
6. Pack smarter inside first
- Soft duffels squeeze into gaps that hard suitcases can't.
- Compression or vacuum bags shrink bulky bedding and jackets.
- Check the under-floor storage in your cargo area; many SUVs hide a useful well there.
- Keep heavy items low and against the seat backs so they can't fly forward in a hard stop.
- Don't stack above the rear window. If you can't see out, the load goes on the roof or the hitch.
How much weight can you put on your roof?
This is the question that matters most, and the answer is always the lowest of these ratings:
- Your vehicle's roof load limit. It's in your owner's manual, and it's often the lowest number of all.
- Your roof rails, if your car has them.
- Your crossbars. ERKUL publishes real working numbers: Skybar is rated up to 165 lb while driving; Wizard and AeroGlide up to 220 lb while driving; Strong up to 220 lb.
- Your carrier. For example, the AeroGlide Basket is rated 175 lb.
Everything on the roof counts toward that number: the bars, the carrier and the cargo together. Heavy loads like coolers, tools and firewood are better on a hitch carrier, which doesn't touch your roof limit at all.
Before every trip: the 60-second check
- Shake each crossbar and carrier firmly. If anything moves, re-tighten before you drive.
- Re-check straps after the first few miles and at every stop.
- Your car is taller now: watch garages, parking decks, drive-throughs and low branches.
- Slow down in strong crosswinds; a loaded roof catches the wind.
- Remove roof carriers before an automatic car wash.
Which crossbars do you need?
Options 1 to 3 start with crossbars, and ERKUL makes vehicle-specific bars for every roof type:
- AeroGlide: our quietest bar, rated to 220 lb while driving. The pick for long highway trips and cars with a sunroof.
- Wizard: extended bar tips for wide loads like roof boxes and kayaks, rated to 220 lb while driving.
- Skybar: the slim, everyday bar and our lowest-priced system, rated to 165 lb while driving.
- Strong: full metal mounts for the heaviest loads, rated to 220 lb.
- Falcon: for bare roofs with no rails; it clamps to the door frame.
Every ERKUL crossbar ships as a complete kit, installs in about 15 minutes without drilling, locks, and has a T-track channel on top, so ERKUL carriers and most other brands' carriers fit. Still deciding? Compare all five systems side by side.
Bundle and save: add a carrier to your crossbar order (roof basket, bike, ski or kayak rack, or a hitch carrier) and save at least 20% on it, automatically at checkout. No code needed.
Get the right bars for your exact car
Pick your year, make and model and see only what fits.
Find my fit →- ✓ Guaranteed fit for your exact vehicle
- ✓ Free US ground shipping from our New Jersey warehouse
- ✓ Limited Lifetime Warranty on crossbars (2 years on carriers)
- ✓ 30-day returns and real people on the phone, Mon–Sat
Frequently asked questions
Can I put luggage on my roof rails without crossbars?
Not safely. Factory side rails run front to back and aren't designed to carry a load on their own. Crossbars span the roof side to side, and that's what baskets, bags and boxes clamp to. If your rails came without crossbars, you'll need a set that matches your rail type.
Roof basket or roof box: which is better?
A box wins for suitcases you want dry and locked. A basket wins for bulky or oddly shaped gear, and it costs less. If you mostly carry heavy or dirty gear and have a hitch, a hitch carrier beats both.
Does a roof carrier hurt gas mileage?
Yes. Anything on the roof adds wind drag. The DOE's numbers for a large roof box are about 6% to 17% worse on the highway, versus 1% to 5% for a rear-mount carrier. Take roof carriers off when you're not using them.
Can I go through a car wash with a roof basket?
No. Remove roof baskets and other carriers before any automatic car wash.
Will a hitch cargo carrier fit my car?
The TrekHaul fits a standard 2-inch hitch receiver. If your car doesn't have a hitch, you'll need one installed first. Always stay under your hitch's tongue-weight rating.
My car has no roof rails. Can I still carry luggage on the roof?
Yes. Bare-roof crossbars like ERKUL Falcon clamp to the door frames and take the same carriers as any other crossbar. Our guide to roof racks for cars without rails covers your options.
How long does it take to install ERKUL crossbars?
About 15 minutes, no drilling, with the Allen key in the box. Stuck? Book a free live video call and an ERKUL tech walks you through it, Mon–Sat, 8AM–8PM EST.
Not sure what fits? Ask a real person.
Text or call us with your year, make and model, and we'll tell you exactly what fits before you order.
Text 609-245-6424  · Call  · support@orkulautousa.shop
Mon–Sat, 8AM–8PM EST, from Mt. Laurel, New Jersey
Keep reading: What roof rails do I have? · Roof racks for cars without rails · Do I need crossbars if I have roof rails? · How to carry skis and snowboards
Carrier guides: Hitch carrier vs roof basket · How to carry bikes · How to carry a kayak
Vehicle guides: Kia Telluride · Subaru Outback · Toyota RAV4 &m
