Free US Shipping from NJMade in TürkiyeLimited Lifetime WarrantyReal Support 6 Days a Week

Hitch Cargo Carrier vs Roof Basket: Which Is Better?

4 min read
Hitch Cargo Carrier vs Roof Basket: Which Is Better?

Quick answer

Choose a hitch cargo carrier if your car has a 2-inch receiver and you haul heavy, bulky or dirty gear: it carries more (300 lb on the ERKUL TrekHaul), loads at waist height, and costs far less fuel. Choose a roof basket if you have no hitch, want your rear hatch and backup camera clear, or carry light, bulky gear: it rides on your crossbars and is rated 175 lb. For the biggest trips, many families run both.

Both put extra cargo outside the car. They solve different problems, though, and picking the wrong one means lifting coolers over your head, or losing access to your trunk at every stop. Here's the side-by-side.

Hitch cargo carrier vs roof basket, side by side

Hitch cargo carrier (TrekHaul) Roof basket (AeroGlide Basket)
Needs 2-inch receiver, Class III or higher Crossbars
Rated load 300 lb (and never more than your hitch's tongue-weight rating) 175 lb (and the basket, bars and cargo must stay under your roof limit)
Size 58" x 20" 51" x 36"
Loading Waist height Overhead
Fuel economy Rear-mount carriers: about 1% to 5% on the highway (DOE) Roof cargo adds drag; a large roof box costs 6% to 17% on the highway (DOE)
Rear access May limit tailgate or trunk access, depending on your vehicle Fully free
Weather cover Add the TrekHaul 15 cu ft bag, water-resistant once zipped Use a cargo net or straps; pack gear in dry bags
Price $199.99 (bag $60.99) $179.99 (plus crossbars if you don't have them)

On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column. Fuel figures: U.S. Department of Energy, fueleconomy.gov.

Choose the hitch cargo carrier if...

  • Your car has a 2-inch receiver, Class III or higher. TrekHaul doesn't fit 1.25-inch receivers, and no adapter is included.
  • You carry heavy or dirty gear: coolers, firewood, tools, wet camping gear. It holds 300 lb, and none of it counts against your roof limit.
  • You'd rather not lift loads overhead, especially on a tall SUV.
  • You drive a lot of highway miles and care about fuel economy.
ERKUL TrekHaul hitch cargo carrier, 58 x 20 inch steel

ERKUL TrekHaul Hitch Cargo Carrier

58" x 20" powder-coated steel · rated 300 lb · 2" receiver · hitch pin and clip included

$199.99

Shop the hitch carrier
ERKUL TrekHaul 15 cubic foot hitch cargo bag

ERKUL TrekHaul Hitch Cargo Bag

15 cu ft · heavy 525gsm PVC · water-resistant once zipped · straps onto your hitch carrier

$60.99

Shop the cargo bag

Hitch carrier tips: check the hitch pin and fasteners before every trip and give the carrier a shake in the receiver. Strap or net everything, and keep cargo clear of your taillights and license plate.

Choose the roof basket if...

  • Your car has no hitch, or you don't want one.
  • You need your trunk, tailgate and backup camera clear at every stop.
  • You carry bulky but lighter gear: duffels, camping chairs, a spare tire, sports gear.
  • You don't want a carrier that adds length to the car when you park or reverse.
ERKUL AeroGlide roof cargo basket, 51 x 36 inch steel

ERKUL AeroGlide Roof Cargo Basket

51" x 36" powder-coated steel · rated 175 lb · wind fairing · fits round, square, oval and aero crossbars

$179.99

Shop the roof basket

Roof basket tips: it fits crossbars up to about 93 mm wide, spaced 27.5" to 36.6" apart. Keep cargo low and centered under a cargo net or ratchet straps, slow down in crosswinds and on rough roads, and remove the basket before an automatic car wash.

Bundle and save: buying crossbars? Add the roof basket or the hitch carrier to the same order and save at least 20% on it, automatically at checkout. No code needed.

Or use both

For a family road trip, the combination is hard to beat: soft, bulky luggage in the roof basket, and the cooler, firewood and heavy bins on the hitch carrier. Each stays within its own limit, and you keep the cabin for people. Just keep the basket, bars and cargo under your roof limit, and the hitch load under your hitch's tongue-weight rating.

Pick your carrier

Have a hitch? Go TrekHaul. No hitch? Start with crossbars and the AeroGlide Basket.

Hitch carrier → Roof basket → Crossbars →
  • ✓ Free US ground shipping from New Jersey
  • ✓ Limited Lifetime Warranty on carriers
  • ✓ Real people on the phone, Mon–Sat, 8AM–8PM EST

Frequently asked questions

Is a hitch cargo carrier better than a roof basket?

For heavy gear and fuel economy, yes: it carries 300 lb at waist height, and rear-mount carriers cost far less fuel than roof cargo. A roof basket is the better pick when you have no hitch or need your rear hatch free.

Will a hitch cargo carrier block my trunk?

It can, depending on your vehicle. Check your tailgate or trunk clearance with the carrier installed before loading.

What size hitch do I need?

A 2-inch receiver, Class III or higher. 1.25-inch receivers aren't supported, and no adapter is included.

Does a roof basket need crossbars?

Yes. The basket clamps onto crossbars and doesn't include its own. If your car has rails only, add crossbars first; see do I need crossbars if I have roof rails?

Can I put the TrekHaul bag on my roof?

No. The TrekHaul Cargo Bag is built to sit on a hitch-mounted carrier only.

Not sure which carrier fits your car?

Text us your year, make and model and what you're hauling. We'll recommend the right setup.

Text 609-245-6424  ·  Call  ·  support@orkulautousa.shop
Mon–Sat, 8AM–8PM EST, from Mt. Laurel, New Jersey

Keep reading: All 6 ways to carry extra luggage · How to carry bikes on your car · Roof racks for cars without rails

Vehicle guides: Kia Telluride · Subaru Outback · Toyota RAV4 · Volvo XC90

Browse all: Vehicle guides · Carrier guides · Roof rack basics

Back to Carrier Guides
Shop carriers
SELECT YOUR VEHICLE